Skip to main content

What is the solution to the GP Workforce crisis?

By Puja Verma, GPST1

There are not enough GPs to meet the current demand. Not enough junior doctors are choosing general practice and an increasing number GPs are leaving full time practice.  The Government plans to meet the increasing demand on our National Health Service by transferring care into primary and community settings, but without more GPs this will not be possible. So how do we inspire a new generation of junior doctors to enter General practice? With a positive recruitment video? With a letter outlining the positive aspects of the profession?  These are both recruitment strategies suggested by the £10 million10 point plan by NHS England.
 
 I undertook a systematic review of strategies used to recruit and retain family doctors. I found 51 evaluations of 42 interventions implemented across 8 high income countries. Interventions were categorised into thirteen groups including retainer schemes, re-entry schemes, support for professional development or research, well-being or peer support initiatives, and specialised recruiters/ case managers. Most of these interventions were badly evaluated without comparison groups therefore we were unable to form strong conclusions from them. However, we did find weak evidence to support undergraduate and postgraduate placements in primary care in underserved areas. This means trainees who were placed in these areas for their training tended to go on to work there in their future careers.

We also found evidence to support selective recruitment of medical students who were from underserved areas or who had started medical school with a particular interest in general practice, these students tended to go on to become GP trainees. We found mixed evidence for financial incentives. There are many different ways to financially incentivise trainees e.g. paying back there loans, or paying them to work in a hard to staff area. Some of these strategies work better than others. 
 
The future of medical school entry may no longer just be based on good grades and personal statements, we might need to start considering the students background and likelihood of becoming GPs. Medical schools need to emphasise the importance of promoting primary care through positive primary care placements throughout their undergraduate training.  Financial incentives may also be necessary when recruiting in particularly hard to staff areas.

Our research showed there is a multitude of incentives out there but they are poorly evaluated, and therefore we are not learning from them. We need to start thinking outside the box, and implementing novel strategies after rigorous evaluation.

 
Have a read of the full paper here: 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A View from the Community - Dr Dana Beale

As part of our View from the Community series of articles, our Year 6 Specialty Choice Lead Dr Ros Herbert interviewed community teacher Dr Dana Beale, to get the inside track on what it's like being a community teacher for Imperial College. To read more articles like this, please sign up to our newsletter by emailing b.broglia@imperial.ac.uk

Dana, tell me what first got you interested in homeless medicine? "Incredibly I was inspired by the same module I did as a student at Imperial College that I am now teaching on! Back then it was 'medical and social care of the homeless' and was based at the surgery for the homeless in Great Chapel Street - a fabulous service that showed me that primary care tailored to this vulnerable and challenging group existed and I promised myself there and then that I would return to work in this field."

What makes you so enthusiastic about this work? "I find this line of work a breath of fresh air; at times incredibly challenging …

Introducing the WATCCH Project - Widening Access to Careers in Community Healthcare

The Undergraduate Primary Care Education team in the Department of Primary Care and Public Health at Imperial College London has kicked off an exciting new work experience programme called WATCCH – Widening Access to Careers in Community Healthcare.
There is a shortage of work experience in the health sector for pupils, particularly for those who have no connection to healthcare professionals. WATCCH aims to open up work experience opportunities in the healthcare sector by offering placements for sixth form pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds to shadow various allied healthcare professionals in general practices. These 16/17 year olds have completed their GCSEs with good grades, do not have placements elsewhere, and are the first in their family applying to university. 
Pupils will attend a pre-placement induction at Imperial College's Charing Cross Hospital Campus, and will then have a 3-day work experience session at a general practice where they will observe a variety of allie…

What makes a good placement?

In the New Year, Dr Kevin Patel a GP ST3 on the Imperial VTS, takes a reflective look at the factors that go into making a good clinical attachment for trainees.
As GP trainees we are ‘encouraged’ to reflect; challenging encounters with patients, conversations with colleagues that could have gone better, moments when you felt like you were born to do this job. All of this is good fodder for your ePortfolio.
Not one to miss out on a reflective opportunity, I took a step back from a discussion that was taking place about difficult rotations, a conversation I imagine that is oft-repeated amongst GPs and hospital doctors up and down the country, and thought about how we could use our experience as GP trainees to feed into this.
As trainees we rotate into diverse placements, from paediatrics to public health to care of the elderly. I counted at least 15 distinct departments I have worked in since finishing medical school just over 5 years ago. This is more than any other specialty trainee…